
So, you've decided to try tampons. Now comes the confusing part: which one are you supposed to buy?
Regular or Super? What does absorbency even mean? And what's the difference between a tampon with an applicator and one without?
If you've always used pads, it's completely normal to have questions. Tampon packaging can look confusing when you're not familiar with the terminology.
The good news? Choosing your first tampon is simpler than it looks. You mainly need to understand three things: absorbency, applicator type and what feels comfortable for you.
Let's break it down.
1. Tampon sizes: What do the different absorbencies mean?
First, let's clear up a common misconception.
Tampon sizes are primarily about absorbency, not your body size or how experienced you are with tampons.
Different tampons are designed to absorb different amounts of menstrual flow. The right one depends on how much you bleed, which can vary throughout your period.
Here's a simple guide.
| Absorbency | Generally suited for | When you might use it |
|---|---|---|
| Light | Very light flow | Start or end of your period |
| Regular | Light to medium flow | Lighter or moderate days |
| Super | Medium to heavier flow | Heavier days |
| Super+ | Very heavy flow | Extra heavy days |
These descriptions are general guides. Actual absorbency depends on the product, so always check its packaging.
You might use Regular on one day and Super on another. There's no need to stick to just one absorbency throughout your period.
The golden rule: Choose the lowest absorbency that adequately manages your flow.
A higher absorbency isn't automatically better, even on a heavier day. The aim is to find one that works for your flow without being unnecessarily absorbent.

2. How do you know which absorbency to choose?
If you're new to tampons, you might not know how heavy your flow is in terms of tampon absorbency. That's okay.
You can start by considering your usual period pattern.
On lighter days
You may need a lower absorbency. If your flow is very light, insertion and removal can feel less comfortable because there is less menstrual fluid for the tampon to absorb.
On heavier days
You may need a higher absorbency to manage your flow. If your tampon leaks sooner than expected, consider whether a higher absorbency is appropriate.
If you're unsure
Start with the lowest absorbency you think will adequately manage your flow, and follow the product instructions.
Pay attention to how the tampon performs when you remove it. If it remains relatively dry and feels uncomfortable to remove, you may be using a higher absorbency than you need. If it leaks quickly, you may need a different absorbency or to change it sooner.
Remember to change tampons every 4โ8 hours and never wear one for more than 8 hours.
You don't need to get your choice perfect on the first try. Learning what works for your body can take a little time.
3. Tampons with applicators vs. without: Which should you choose?
Another decision you'll come across is whether to choose an applicator tampon or a non-applicator tampon.
Neither is universally better. The difference is in how the tampon is inserted.
Tampons with applicators
An applicator is a tube that helps guide the absorbent tampon into the vagina.
Depending on the design, it may be made from plastic or cardboard. The applicator helps position the tampon, which some beginners find easier when learning how to use one.
Why you might prefer one:
- The applicator guides the tampon into place.
- You don't need to push the absorbent part in directly with your fingers.
- Some designs are compact and easy to carry in your bag.
Tampons without applicators
Non-applicator tampons are inserted using your fingers.
They typically have a compact shape and less packaging, but you'll need to guide the tampon into place yourself.
Why you might prefer one:
- The design is simple and compact.
- There's no applicator to dispose of.
- You have direct control over positioning the tampon.
For someone trying tampons for the first time, an applicator may feel more straightforward because it provides a guide for insertion. However, comfort and preference vary from person to person.
If you're unsure where to begin, choose the type whose instructions you understand and feel comfortable following.

4. What is a compact applicator tampon?
If you're choosing an applicator tampon, you may also come across compact designs.
A compact applicator is designed to take up less space before use. Depending on the design, it extends into its ready-to-use position before insertion.
This can be useful if you carry your period essentials in a small handbag, pouch or work bag.
For beginners, the key consideration is whether the applicator feels manageable and whether its instructions are easy to follow.
Before using one, familiarise yourself with how it extends and how the tampon is released.

5. What if you're scared of inserting a tampon?
If you've always used pads, the idea of inserting something into your body might feel unfamiliar.
You might wonder whether it will hurt, whether you'll insert it correctly or whether you'll be able to remove it.
These are reasonable questions, and you don't need to feel embarrassed about asking them.
A few things to remember:
- Take your time and choose a position that feels comfortable.
- Follow the instructions supplied with your tampon.
- When using an applicator, guide it towards your lower back rather than straight upwards.
- A correctly positioned tampon should feel comfortable.
- Never force insertion or push through pain.
If you experience persistent pain or difficulty inserting or removing a tampon, stop and consult a healthcare professional.
You also don't have to learn everything at once. If you'd like a step-by-step walkthrough, read our guide to how to use a tampon for the first time.
6. Which tampon should you choose for your first try?
Let's bring everything together.
When choosing your first tampon, consider these three questions:
What's my flow like?
Choose an absorbency that adequately manages your menstrual flow. Regular may work for lighter to moderate days, while Super may be more suitable for heavier days.
Would an applicator make me feel more comfortable?
If you're unfamiliar with tampon insertion, an applicator may provide a helpful guide. A compact design can also be convenient to carry.
Would I prefer to try different absorbencies before committing to a full box?
You don't need to buy multiple full boxes just to discover what works for you.
At heysarah, we created the 3-Day Switch Kit to make that first step a little easier.
It contains 5 Regular and 3 Super tampons, giving you the opportunity to try both absorbencies and see what works for your flow.
No need to guess your way through your first purchase. Start small, learn at your own pace and find what feels right for you.
Frequently asked questions
Which absorbency is better for beginners?
Neither is automatically better for beginners. Choose based on your menstrual flow, and use the lowest absorbency that adequately manages it.
Is a smaller tampon easier to insert?
Physical dimensions and absorbency aren't the same thing. A tampon's shape and design can affect how it feels to insert, while its absorbency determines how much menstrual fluid it is designed to absorb. Follow the product instructions and choose an option you feel comfortable using.
Are applicator tampons better for beginners?
An applicator can help guide the tampon into place, which some beginners find useful. Some applicators like heysarahโs BPA-free plastic applicators are designed to be ultra-smooth and soft, to reduce friction during insertion, for a more comfortable first experience.
Can I use different absorbencies during the same period?
Yes. Your flow can change from day to day, so you may find that different absorbencies work better at different points in your period.
How often should I change my tampon?
Change your tampon every 4โ8 hours and never wear one for more than 8 hours. Follow the product instructions and use the lowest absorbency that adequately manages your flow.
Your first tampon doesn't have to be complicated
Choosing your first tampon comes down to understanding your flow, deciding whether you prefer an applicator and finding an option you're comfortable using.
You don't need to know everything before you start. Take your time, follow the instructions and give yourself space to figure out what works for you.
Ready to try tampons?
The heysarah 3-Day Switch Kit includes 5 Regular and 3 Super tampons, so you can explore both absorbencies without committing to a full box of each.

